| Discussion and Response
to the Remedy:
The obvious remedies in this analysis were Natrum Mur, Sulphur,
Ignatia and Aurum. But none of them fitted the whole
picture. She told me that she always felt better when she took Sulphur
– “it is good for my system and seems to suit me”. But it
never brought about any lasting relief over the last 3-4 years.
This information allowed me to consider the possibility of Natrum
Sulph or Aurum Sulph. I realized that Natrum Sulph
was more prominently Psora-Sycotic Miasm, while Aurum Sulph
would be more Psora-Syphilitic, given the combination of elements.
From her past history and family history of diseases suffered, the
analysis was a Psora-Syphilitic expression rather than Psora-Sycotic.
When talking with her, I understood that the central and most limiting
factor for her was the joylessness she felt in her heart, with no
value for her life and the constant suicidal feeling associated
with it. The suppressed grief and anger was just a small part of
her disturbance. It is the most prominent symptoms of mental state
decide the predominant miasmatic expression. I see Joylessness with
a suicidal tendency as syphilitic expressions. If suppressed grief
and anger was more limiting it would point to a Sycotic expression.
The 3 rubrics in red were the deciding rubrics for me. So Aurum
Sulph was a better choice over Natrum Sulph from the
Miasmatic perspective as well.
She told me that she had been given Nat Mur many times in
the past which had never helped. In fact she would either prove
it or aggravate on it emotionally. She had also been given Thuja
which did very little.
After the first dose of Aurum Sulph 200, here is her followup:
"I guess what is astonishing about all of this is after taking
the aurum sulph, I began to put on weight very quickly about 6
kilos in 5 weeks, all digestation problems were remarkably improved
and physical energy had improved dramatically. Three weeks after
taking it I did a 22km trek up to Gomuk with no adverse effects.
Also As we had to stay in Gomuk at few days due to landslides,
I had to eat what I would say was not very hygienically prepared
food again with no adverse effects."
So far she has had about 4 doses of the 200C. She says that no
other remedy so far has agreed with her so well, and though she
may have a long way to go emotionally and spiritually, she certainly
feels she’s on her way to deep recovery. She has felt following
the remedy, short episodes of deep joy - when she went for a swim
in the sea – which was deeply exhilarating, something she has not
felt in years.
4 months on Aurum Sulph 200, this is her follow-up in the
first week of August:
“With regards to physical symptoms, no diarrhea, semi solid
to solid stools every day. Minimum gas and bloating. I’m eating
a normal diet and no problem with it. Do feel plugged
up following meals sometimes or if i eat extra which can be uncomfortable.
Grinding of teeth at night (old symptom). Do use gum guard
but spit it out during night. Lots of hair loss, falling out in
bunches (old symptom). Blocked nose sometimes, sneezing and
watery eyes , possibly due to damp in flat , although flat was treated
for damp. Blocked nose worse for lying down and when i wake up in
morning (Old Symptom).
Was having difficulty sleeping at night, checking all rooms in flat
when i hear a noise, having frightful dreams that robbers are going
to break in .One night i was sure I heard the robber shout my name
through the letter box. it seemed so real. This has started to improve
the last few nights. Feel like i am too sensitive for all of this.
When i 'm out i worry about how I'm going to get home, if I’m safe
etc. Don't feel like this in India.
On visitng my home country I observed how my half
sisters are so close to dad and stepmother. They are very affectionate
with each other, sharing hugs and kisses and telling them their
problems. I envy this and when I see it, I feel I don't know real
love or never had real love. I'm sure my mother loved me , but I
just don't remember it. I certainly don't share the closeness they
have and am not close to anyone in my life.
My aunt told my father that she had found a letter written by my
mother. The letter had enclosed some money, so my aunt could buy
me and sis sweets. It's one of the rare occasions I hear anything
about my mother, especially in relation to me. This brought tears
to my eyes but I didn’t respond. Even though I would really like
to have the letter but am afraid of opening the can of worms and
causing pain to me, dad etc.
I find my father's company very hard to tolerate. I can only
be in his presence for 30 minutes at a time. I find him overbearing
and his physical presence disgusts me. Some of his mannerisms also
disgust me like touching my food as he puts it on my plate, I could
scream at him. Sometimes I look at him and, I just feel repulsed.
I know when Dad passes away I will be deeply affected by
it. I know he will do anything for me.
Sometimes I fell really sad for no reason and tears will come to
my eyes but it passes.
Came back home and took 200 Aurum Sulph that night, 25th
July. Again feel as if i am just watching myself exist. I feel like
I am existing and not living. You asked me if I have the ability
to feel joy (subsequent to the remedy). YEs on very rare
occasions and for a very short time. I would say I am depressed,
no joy, however one big change is right now I could not imagine
killing myself. The desire to commit suicide is gone, but the desire
to die is still lingering. Thoughts of suicide have been with me
on and off but always in the background for many years (8-9).
Maybe I should have said i feel a lack of joy as opposed to
being depressed or is it the same thing , I'm not sure. Also, what
gets me down is the fact that I 'm back to routine. Soon, I will
be getting a train to work every am, same thing day in day out.
Yawn. I'm adverse to work when I'm not there but will work hard
whilst there.”
MIND; FEAR; robbers, of (K47, SI-520, G37) (knaves)
MIND; AVERSION; family members, to (K9, SI-104, G8)
MIND; WORK; fatigues (SI-1098)
MIND; AILMENTS from; love; disappointed, unhappy (K63, SI-20, G50)
HEAD; HAIR; affections of; falling out, alopecia (K120, G100) (baldness)
I wanted to check whether Aurum Sulph still covered this picture
and so I did a short analysis above. Aurum (Met) came up on top
covering all rubrics along with Conium and Nat Mur as differentials.
Her hair loss improved after the dose as well as the fear of robbers.
It helped her sleep well. I suggested that the next dose should
be a 1M of Aurum Sulph instead, as the 200 action did not seem to
last long enough.
Here is her last followup:
"Took 1M on 25th August as emotionally I was going down the
slippery slope of depression. The following day I listened to bhajans,
chanting and cried a few tears, another emotional meltdown. Since
then I have been feeling much more postitive. Depression has
lifted and physical symptoms all getting better.Sleeping well, no
nightmares, plugged up feeling gone. Aurum sulphur is definetely
right for me, I guess I burn up the energy of it pretty quickly.
There is still some hairloss."
She continues to respond in a positive direaction. I think this
is a classic state of Aurum Sulph. Time will still tell
whether she will need another remedy or intercurrent remedies. For
the moment though, this looks like a good constitutional remedy.
Vermeullens Synoptic says this:
LEADING SYMPTOMS
M Censorious.
"In the foreground,
there is introversion, and a critical attitude to himself and particularly
to others. Seldom satisfied with himself and others. As a result,
often ill-tempered; can be clumsy." [Vithoulkas]
"Usually they have a strong desire to improve
others by telling them what they should do. They feel that they
know what is best for others, and that they have the right to correct
and criticise others." [Wulfsberg]
M Desire to be alone.
Taciturn. Quarrelsome.
M Very useful remedy for chronic
complaints that date back to grief. [Kent]
M Indolence # mania for work.
He is becoming weak-minded
and indolent; will not work, becomes like a tramp. These states
change to excitement and a mania for work. [Kent]
"Desire to be effective. In order to be effective
they try to do several things at once." [Wulfsberg]
M It should become an excellent
remedy for insanity, irresolution and extreme irritability; moaning
and lamenting. [Kent]
M Hurried state of mind,
but doing things
in a hurry < [e.g. running].
M VIVID DREAMS.
"All Aurums have
vivid, horrifying, terrifying dreams. The Aurum sulph. can, occasionally,
have pleasant dreams – it is the only one." [Priestman]
"Dreams of thieves, assassins, etc." [Allen]
M Two types:
c The open type:
lively, social, extroverted, impulsive and easy going.
"They don't tend to take themselves seriously
and can laugh at themselves and their mistakes at home, but not
at work. Due to restlessness they have a desire for change and to
travel. Like Sulphur they can have many plans and ideas. … Their
main motive is to invent or do something that gives them fame, approbation
and recognition." [Wulfsberg]
c The reserved type:
much less impulsive, more reserved and controlled.
M "Directness and aversion to
company. The Aurum sulphuricum patient is an open and direct person,
who clearly states his opinion and doesn't hide his emotions. He
usually is powerful and energetic. You often find a kind of roughness
in his way of speaking, from which you can feel that he has the
strength to impose himself if necessary. Aurum-s. patients always
prefer to be alone. A distinct aversion to company is a must for
the prescription of this remedy." [Springer, Hom. Links 1/97] |