| Homeopathy (also spelled homœopathy
or homoeopathy), from the Greek words homoios (similar) and pathos
(suffering), is a system of medicine, notable for its practice of
prescribing water-based solutions that do not contain chemically
active ingredients. The theory of homeopathy was developed by the
Saxon physician Samuel Hahnemann (1755–1843) and first published
in 1796. It has a wide and growing popularity in areas where it
is practiced today, but the way homeopathy
medicines work and many of the fundamental principles of homeopathy
like the theory of the vital force and chronic miasms are still
hotly debated.
Homeopathy calls
for treating "like with like" (law of similars). The practitioner
considers the totality of symptoms of a given case. He or she then
chooses a remedy that has been reported in a homeopathic
proving to produce a similar set of symptoms in healthy subjects.
This remedy is usually given in extremely low concentrations prepared
according to a procedure known as potentisation (see the Principle
of Dilution below), because it is held that this process gives
higher dilutions more therapeutic power.
History of Homeopathy
Homeopathy was developed by
Dr Samuel Hahnemann (1755-1843) starting with his
recognition of the Law of Simila as a general therapeutic
law. Although people like Hippocrates and Paracelsus (born around
1493), had proposed & used similar ideas in their times, it
was Dr. Hahnemann who first recognised & applied this therapeutic
principle as a general law.
In the 18th century, the medical science was still very unscientific.
The knowledge about human body, diseases and the modalities of treatment
were poor and vague. Methods like blood-letting, leeching, purging
were the common treatments for most ailments. Practically the whole
of the 18th century in Europe was marked by a plethora of theories
and hypothesis concerning the nature of disease and its causation.
Consequently methods of therapeutic practice were as numerous and
diverse as the theories propounded. The uncertainty and lack of
any fixed principle of healing disappointed Dr. Hahnemann.
So Dr. Hahnemann relinquished his medical practice & devoted
himself to the translation of great medical classics of his time.
In 1790, when Dr. Hahnemann was engaged in translating William Cullen's
(a Scottish physician) materia medica from English to German, his
attention was arrested by the remark of the author that cinchona
bark cured malaria because of its bitterness & tonic effects
on stomach. This explanation appeared unsatisfactory to him. In
his youth he had travelled in a particular area of Hungary where
Marsh Fever or Malaria had been rife. He had used the herb, Cinchina
Bark, but his experience did not support the conclusion of Cullen's
paper. He decided to carry out some experiments of his own.
He took a dose of the herb himself and he found that he developed
symptoms very much like Marsh Fever. He realised that the cure of
the disease could cause the symptoms of the disease. He tried it
on his family, friends and volunteers and they all developed the
same sort of symptoms. He experimented with this one drug on many
people and the majority of them told the same story. In 1796, after
6 years of Dr. Hahnemann's first experiment, he published an article
in Hufeland's Journal volume-II, parts 3 & 4, pages 391-439
& 465-561. "An essay on a new principle for ascertaining
the curative powers of drugs & some examinations of the previous
principle."
Like Cures Like
So he developed the principle that a
substance which will create the symptoms of a disease in a healthy
person will actually cure the symptoms of the disease in a sick
person. Hahnemann
called this principle "similia similibus curentur"
or "let like be cured by like". He went on to "prove",
as it is called, some 67 remedies on his many healthy students,
family and friends. His findings were published in Materia Medica
Pura of 1810. Many of the substances Hahnemann
used were highly poisonous, for example arsenic and mercury, and
to avoid the toxic effect, he experimented with smaller and smaller
doses. By experimentation, he found that successive dilutions of
a substance became progressively more medicinally active, and less
toxic.
Homeopathy Principles
Homeopathy as a science of
medical treatment has a philosophy of its own and its therapeutics
is based on certain fundamental principles. These are:
- Law of Similia
- Law of Simplex
- Law of Minimum
- Doctrine of Drug Proving
- Theory of Chronic Disease
- Theory of Vital Force
- Doctrine of Drug-Dynamisation
The law of similars
The first and most important "natural law" expressed
by Hahnemann, the
one from which homeopathy derives its name, is similia similibus
curentur—let like cure like. This means that the appropriate
substance to treat a disease is one which induces similar symptoms
in a healthy person. Then, it is crucial to know the symptoms associated
with various substances, remedial pathogeneses. They are to be determined
by drug provings on healthy
persons, in which subjects take the remedy and record all physical,
mental, emotional and modal changes in symptoms.
The Principle of Dilution
Hahnemann developed the system of homeopathic dilution, where
one part of the starting material (usually plant extract) is diluted
with 99 parts of diluent (usually alcohol and water). The mixture
is then "succussed" or "potentised", which is
a rhythmical shaking of the liquid which helps to release the energy
within the substance. The dilution is called a 1C homeopathic potency.
The process of dilution can be repeated with the 1C potency to make
a 2C potency, and so on until the desired potency is reached. Hahnemann
discovered that by administering infinitesimally small doses, he
not only cured ailments without undesirable side effects but in
fact the cure was more effective than with larger doses. Later two
more scales for menufacturing homeopathic medicines were created.
The Decimal scale developed by Hering uses the 1:9 ratio for successive
dilution, whereas the LM scale given by Dr. Hahnemann uses a dilution
scale of 1:50,000.
To read in detail all the principles of homeopathy, click
here.
Homeopathic philosophy
Modern science recognizes that an organism's response to stress
occurs in a highly organized and interrelated manner. In homeopathy
the concept of homeostatic balance on physical levels is expanded
to include the mental and emotional realms as well. In other words,
one's body, mind and emotions are viewed as always working to maintain
a relative degree of homeostasis or balance. Because the body, mind
and emotions respond in unity to stress, the homeopathic approach
to understanding disease is holistic. This means an attempt is made
to evaluate any problem in the context of the whole person--physically,
mentally and emotionally--and to understand how the person is limited.
The homeopathic approach does
not combat disease symptoms in the same manner as one would in conventional
practice. Instead, homeopathic philosophy states that if the organism
is brought back into balance, the symptoms of disease (imbalance)
will resolve accordingly. The homeopathic
means to this end is unique to each person; therefore, whereas a
conventional diagnosis is based on a defined set of common symptoms,
and will be treated conventionally with common treatments, a homeopath
looks for a broad and unique picture of imbalance specific to each
person.
An example of this difference between conventional and homeopathic
practice can be made by looking at how each would approach an inflammatory
condition. Conventional practitioners might view a chronic inflammatory
disease as the result of an overly-aggressive immune system, and
could make a diagnosis based upon a pattern of common symptoms.
They could then choose from any number of anti-inflammatory or immune-modulating
agents, hoping to suppress the problem.
For a homeopath, the signs and symptoms of inflammation are just
the starting point for understanding the full breadth of disease.
The common signs of inflammation--'rubor, calor, dolor and tumor'--are
simply the tip of the iceberg. A conventional diagnosis would not
be specific enough for selection of a remedy, and one would need
to consider other broader or unique expressions of disease.
The effort to target inflammation alone is also be viewed by homeopaths
as 'suppressive', meaning that although the most obvious symptoms
of imbalance (eg., inflammation) may be quelled, the underlying
stress and imbalance from which this problem arose have not changed.
Therefore, a person with a chronic inflammatory condition is treated
but not cured. Homeopaths also view the effort to suppress symptoms
as one which occurs at the expense of the rest of the organism.
That is, if the organism works as an integrated whole, one cannot
single out and combat individual symptoms without the battle spilling
over in effects on the whole.
Therefore, to rid a person of their chief complaint is not enough
in homeopathy. The improvement must also be in line with a general
'direction of cure'--if a person's chief complaint is resolved,
one should not see a subsequent problem develop at a deeper or more
vital level of function.
Does Homeopathy Work?
Homeopathy has a two hundred year track record of curing illness.
Homeopathy received widepread
public attention through its effectiveness during epidemics of cholera
in the 19th century. During the great influenza epidemic of the
1920's, homeopathic hospitals reported low death rates, while hospitals
employing conventional medicine reported death rates of 20% to 30%.
Since the late '40's, double blind trials testing homeopathy on
various medical conditions have led to mixed results. Some are claimed
to support the use of homeopathy. In other cases, this method of
evaluation proved itself incapable of documenting the success of
homeopathic cures.
In a report published in the September 20, 1997 issue of Lancet,
Dr. Wayne Jonas, head of the Office of Alternative medicine, and
Dr. Klaus Linde, concluded that, when the evidence of the 89 studies
of homeopathy judged to be
of good quality was pooled, homeopathy was deemed to be 2.45
times more effective than placebo.
In 1996, an unpublished study from the Homeopathic Medicine
Research Group, an organization formed by the European Union
to determine the effectiveness of homeopathy, concluded that homeopathy
was more effective than a placebo... and the probability
was only 0.027% that this result might be due to chance! Remarkably,
a group skeptical toward homeopathy had assisted in the study's
design.
In the February 9, 1991 issue of the British Medical Journal,
an analysis by two Dutch researchers asked to assess the efficacy
of various forms of alternative medicine, reported that although
initially they had been sceptics as to homeopathy and alternative
medicine in general, "The amount of positive results
came as a surprise to us... The evidence presented in this
review would probably be sufficient for establishing homeopathy
as a regular treatment for certain indications."
Another, more recent, study stated “Compared with placebo,
homeopathy provoked a clear, significant, and clinically relevant
improvement in nasal inspiratory peak flow, similar to that found
with topical steroids.” British medical Journal August
19th 2000.
Today, as we learn more and become more sensitive to the relationships
between all living things, homeopathy has rightfully attracted the
interest of a great many intelligent, inquisitive and preceptive
minds within both the lay and the medical community.
Growth of Homeopathy
Such was Hahnemman's success, particularly with endemic and epidemic
diseases, that homeopathy quickly spread throughout Europe and across
to America. Dr Fredrick Harvey Foster Quinn introduced homeopathy
into Great Britain in the late 1820's and in 1849 he founded the
London Homeopathic Hospital.
Homeopathy was brought to
America in 1825 and rapidly gained in popularity, partly due to
the fact that the excesses of conventional medicine were especially
extreme there, and partly due to the efforts of Constantine Hering.
Hering developed the doctrine that symptoms always move in a particular
way: from the surface to the interior, from the extremities to the
upper part of the body, and from less vital to more vital organs.
His "Laws of Cure" state that the cure must take place
in the reverse order of the appearance of the symptoms (first in,
last out).
Nearly as important as Hahnemann himself to the development and
popularization of homeopathy was the American physician James Tyler
Kent (1849 – 1921). His most important contribution may be
his repertory, which is still widely used today.
Homeopathy reached its peak of popularity in America in the decades
1865–1885. In the 1930s the popularity of homeopathy began
to wane, especially in Europe and the United States, partly due
to advances in biology and conventional medicine, partly due to
a decline in coherence in the homeopathic community and partly due
to increasing influence of AMA on medical practice. Homeopathy experienced
a renaissance in the 1970s that continues to this day. George
Vithoulkas, who studied in India, where the homeopathic tradition
had remained strong, was instrumental in resurrecting homeopathy
in Europe.
With advent of computer technology, the ease with which large symptom
databases can be used has brought about profound changes in the
way homeopathy is practised. Today a large number of homeopaths
use personal computers to sift through hundreds of thousands of
pages of provings and case studies. The homeopathic repertorisation
software have made practicing homeopathy much more easier.
Where is Homeopathy Popular Now?
Homeopathy is particularly
popular in France, England, Germany, Greece, India, Pakistan, Brazil,
Argentina, Mexico, and South Africa. Approximately 40% of the French
public have used homeopathic medicines, and 39% of the French physicians
have prescribed the medicines. About 20% of German physicians occasionally
utilize these natural medicines, and 45% of Dutch physicians consider
them effective. According to a survey in the British Medical Journal
(June 7, 1986), 42% of British physicians survey refer patients
to homeopathic physicians, and a New York Times article reported
that visits to British homeopaths is growing at a rate of 39% a
year.
Despite these impressive statistics, homeopathy is particularly
popular in India where there are over 180 five-year homeopathic
medical schools. Homeopathy is also growing very rapidly in the
United States. Market research shows that sales of homeopathic medicines
have grown at a rate of 25-50% per year during the past ten years.
There are estimated to be over 500,000 physicians practising homeopathy
world wide, with an estimated 500 million people receiving treatment.
Over twelve thousand medical doctors and licensed health care practitioners
administer homeopathic treatment
in the United Kingdom, France, and Germany. Since 2001 homeopathy
is regulated in the European Union by Directive 2001/83/EC. The
latest amendments to this directive make it compulsory for all member
states to implement a special registration procedure for homeopathic
drugs.
In India, there are nearly 180 homeopathic medical colleges, 7500
government clinics, and 307 hospitals offering homeopathy treatment.
Approximately 35 are government colleges, rest are managed by private
bodies. Homeopathy is the third most popular method of treatment
in India, after Allopathy and Ayurveda. It is estimated that there
are about quarter million homeopaths in India. Nearly 10,000 new
ones add to this number every year. The legal status of homeopathy
in India is very much at par with the conventional medicine.
In the United Kingdom, as in most countries, homeopathic
remedies may be sold over the counter. The UK has five homeopathic
hospitals where treatment, funded by the National Health Service,
is available and there are numerous regional clinics. Homeopathy
has a core of public support, especially in Scotland and also from
the English royal family.
In the United States, homeopathic
remedies are, like all healthcare products, subject to regulation
by the Food and Drug Administration. However, the FDA accords homeopathic
remedies a treatment significantly different from that accorded
to other drugs. Homeopathic products are not required to be approved
by the FDA prior to sale, not required to be proven either safe
or effective prior to being sold, not required to be labeled with
an expiration date, and not required to undergo finished product
testing to verify contents and strength. In the United States only
homeopathic medicines that
claim to treat self-limiting conditions may be sold over the counter,
while homeopathic medicines
that claim to treat a serious disease can be sold only by prescription.
Homeopathy's popularity in the United States is growing. The 1995
retail sales of homeopathic medicines in the United States were
estimated at $201 million and growing at a rate of 20 percent a
year, according to the American Homeopathic Pharmaceutical Association.
The number of homeopathic practitioners in the United States has
increased from fewer than 200 in the 1970s to approximately 3,000
in 1996.
In Germany, about 6,000 physicians specialize in homeopathy. In
1978 homeopathy, along with anthroposophically extended medicine
and herbalism, were recognized as "special forms of therapy",
meaning that their medications are freed from the usual requirement
of proving efficacy. Since January 1, 2004 homeopathic medications,
albeit with some exceptions, are no longer covered by the country's
public health insurance. Most private health insurers continue to
cover homeopathy.
In Austria homeopathy has been a recognized part of the medical
system since 1983. In Switzerland homeopathy is one of the five
classes of complementary medicine.
Useful Links -
Faq about Homeopathy
Benefits of Homeopathy
Myths about Homeopathy
Life History of Samuel
Hahnemann
Scientific Research in Homeopathy
Organon of Medicine ebook
Online Homeopathy Dictionary
Free Introductory Course on Homeopathy
Homeopathic Materia Medica
Homeopathy Repertory
Homeopathy Pharmacology and Pharmacy
Homeopathy Combinations
The
Evolution of Homoeopathy
Cost Effectiveness
& Efficacy of Homeopathy in PHC Units of Delhi
Homeopathy:
The Test - programme summary from BBC
FDA's view
of homeopathy
BBC's "Complementary Medicine" article on Homeopathy |